Electric Arc Furnace (EAF) or Submerged Arc Furnace (SAF)?

In industrial production, especially in the field of metal smelting, electric arc furnaces and submerged arc furnaces are two common and important equipment. In practical applications, choose to use electric arc furnaces or submerged arc furnaces is an important decision that requires comprehensive consideration of many factors.

Electric Arc Furnace (EAF)

First, let's take a closer look at electric arc furnaces. Electric arc furnaces use the high temperatures generated by the electrode arc to melt ores and metals. This direct heat transfer method gives it greater flexibility in handling various types and shapes of charge. For example, for recycling scrap metal, electric arc furnaces can easily handle scrap steel of different sizes and shapes. Moreover, the start and stop of electric arc furnaces are relatively fast, which is suitable for small batches and multi-variety production needs.

However, electric arc furnaces also have some shortcomings. Since the arc is directly exposed to the furnace, the heat loss is relatively large, which leads to low energy efficiency. In addition, the control of arc length and current is complex, requiring operators to have a high level of technical skills and experience.

Submerged Arc Furnace (SAF)

Submerged arc furnaces bury the arc in the charge, and the heat is transferred by conduction and radiation. This method makes the heat loss smaller, thus improving the energy utilization efficiency. For large-scale and continuous production, submerged arc furnace can effectively reduce production costs. At the same time, because the arc is covered by the charge, its operation control is relatively stable, and the technical requirements for the operator are relatively low.

However, the submerged arc furnace is not perfect. It usually requires the charge to have a certain particle size and shape, which limits the range of charge selection to a certain extent. Moreover, the start-up and stop process of the submerged arc furnace is relatively slow, which is not suitable for frequent switching of production tasks.

How to Choose?

If your company is mainly engaged in the recycling of scrap metal, the production tasks are flexible and changeable, and the adaptability requirements of the charge are high, then the electric arc furnace may be a better choice. For example, some small metal recycling plants, due to the wide source of scrap steel and various shapes, the electric arc furnace can better meet their production needs.

On the contrary, if your company needs to carry out large-scale and continuous production, pursue a stable production process and high energy efficiency, and the supply of charge is relatively stable and meets specific particle size and shape requirements, then the submerged arc furnace may be more suitable for you. For example, in the large-scale production of large steel enterprises, submerged arc furnaces can effectively reduce energy consumption and costs while ensuring output and quality.

Summary

The choice of electric arc furnace or submerged arc furnace needs to be comprehensively considered based on the specific production needs of the enterprise, furnace material conditions, energy costs, and the technical level of operators. Only by making the right choice can we maximize economic benefits while improving production efficiency.

E-mail: saleswn@hanrm.com / inquiry66@hanmetallurgy.com (Laura Ma)

Tel / Whatsapp / Wechat: 0086 17791213533

Xi'an Hani Tech Co., Ltd.